Ban smacking

Discussion in 'Off-Topic Discussion' started by clueless1, Dec 28, 2013.

  1. Dave W

    Dave W Total Gardener

    Joined:
    Feb 6, 2006
    Messages:
    6,143
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    Anything I fancy and can afford!
    Location:
    Tay Valley
    Ratings:
    +3,035
    Some very interesting and some wise comments made so far.

    Presumably the purpose of smacking a child put forward by proponents is that it teaches the child something that is of value for the child’s development. This could encompass safety, socialisation, ‘education’ and other aspects. Smacking is easy to administer, takes next to no time and usually results in an apparently contrite child. And, from what I’ve read recently it’s in the bible so must be the thing to do according to one religiously affiliated school.

    An alternative, and sometimes an addition to smacking is verbal chastisement where the child is verbally humiliated with the production of tears being taken as indicative of success.

    Child psychology has made immense strides over the past 40 years in the understanding of how children develop and also in general learning theory. One of the very basic truths of the acquisition of learning is that negative reinforcement doesn’t work as well as positive reinforcement for shaping behaviour. Putting this in a parent-child context, the parent who praises the ‘good’ actions and ignores the ‘bad’, is more likely to raise a happy and well balanced child. Furthermore the child who is smacked learns that might is right, and has already been pointed out the child who is denigrated comes to believe his/hers description.

    The problem with positive reinforcement or at least with soft-peddling the negative is that it takes more time, patience and a bit more thought. It’s not a quick fix though it is the one that lasts.

    I’d like to say that I was smacked by my parents and belted at school and it didn’t do me any harm. It possibly didn’t, but I don’t think it did me much good either.

    We didn’t ever hit either of own two children, though at times were sorely tempted, but they’ve both grown into fine adults with the right set of values, and our daughter who now had her own child is just brilliant with ‘discipline’ (horrible word). Distraction techniques are used to re-direct problematic behaviour, explanation for why mummy is upset and time out on the ‘naughty step’ followed by an “I’m sorry”, seem to be working just fine.

    And as far as Clueless's account about the crossing the road goes. I bet that getting yanked backed and a talking too perhaps created a greater and more lasting impact than the wallop.
     
    • Like Like x 2
    • clueless1

      clueless1 member... yep, that's what I am:)

      Joined:
      Jan 8, 2008
      Messages:
      17,778
      Gender:
      Male
      Location:
      Here
      Ratings:
      +19,598
      Well I didn't do it again.
       
    • clueless1

      clueless1 member... yep, that's what I am:)

      Joined:
      Jan 8, 2008
      Messages:
      17,778
      Gender:
      Male
      Location:
      Here
      Ratings:
      +19,598
      Absolutely. When I first became a dad, my dad said to me, "remember, its far easier to knock the devil into a child than it is to knock the devil out". He went on about rewarding good more than punishing bad. To be honest, so far (touch wood) neither wife nor I have had need to smack our son. The approach I prefer to take is to make him feel included rather than excluded and so far it seems to be working. One piece of advice I read and immediately rejected went like this "you are a father not a friend". That's a load of twaddle. Me and my lads are best mates, and as the older mate, its my job to lead and guide. If someone's not your mate, you don't confide in them, and if my son ever decides he can't confide in me, then simply, I've failed. Wont stop me from smacking his bum though if the situation ever demands it.
       
      • Like Like x 1
      • Dave W

        Dave W Total Gardener

        Joined:
        Feb 6, 2006
        Messages:
        6,143
        Gender:
        Male
        Occupation:
        Anything I fancy and can afford!
        Location:
        Tay Valley
        Ratings:
        +3,035
        My advice as parents of two, grand parents of one, and between Mrs W and myself as teachers of a few hundred, is think twice and don't do it. You'll lose far more than you gain.
         
      • shiney

        shiney President, Grumpy Old Men's Club Staff Member

        Joined:
        Jul 3, 2006
        Messages:
        64,871
        Gender:
        Male
        Occupation:
        Retired - Last Century!!!
        Location:
        Herts/Essex border. Zone 8b
        Ratings:
        +127,052
        Very sage advice :blue thumb:

        Unfortunately, having dealt with thousands of children (usually accompanied by one parent) over the years I've found that a significant number of those parents wouldn't understand the good advice given.

        My fear is that a legal ban on smacking may/would result in a method, ultimately, more harmful being adopted.

        In an ideal situation the ban would be successful but we rarely have anything approaching an ideal situation.

        The area I worked in consisted of a high proportion of socially deprived families and a lot of them didn't possess the vocabulary or verbal dexterity that would encourage them to attempt to use the more gentle methods.
         
        • Like Like x 1
        • Madahhlia

          Madahhlia Total Gardener

          Joined:
          Mar 19, 2007
          Messages:
          3,678
          Gender:
          Female
          Location:
          Suburban paradise
          Ratings:
          +3,090
          I'm neutral about smacking. I think it's best if you can avoid it, but I would not like to see hard-pressed parents being criminalised for doing something that has been a natural recourse throughout history, and is a normal part of parenting in the animal world also. Particularly as legislation would do absolutely nothing to prevent serious abuse, both physical and psychological.

          I agree that the approach of positive reinforcement outlined by Dave W is probably the model of good parenting, but it can go wrong, resulting in spoilt, over-indulged, self-centred brats of the kind that we all long to give a good slap to. Probably the kind that drop the litter that Yvonne Donnellon rightly hates! But that is not the fault of the method, but of the way it has been applied, I think.

          Thinking of my own experience, my dad used to smack me from time to time, but always with a "this hurts me more than it hurts you" approach, never in temper and always with a clear reason. I'm not sure if it did much good, but I certainly did not feel assaulted or damaged by it. He was a good and loving father trying to do his best.

          My mother occasionally smacked me, and once slapped me as a teenager. Her temper was always uncertain and she did not have the patience to deal effectively with small children so her interventions were not effective and made me angry. But again, I don't feel as though I've been damaged by these incidents, no doubt I was a very difficult teenager and my mother was at the end of her tether.

          I know that physical chastisement is often much worse than this but these are examples of parental behaviour that I feel should not be criminalised although possibly sub-optimal.
           
          • Like Like x 3
          • Jenny namaste

            Jenny namaste Total Gardener

            Joined:
            Mar 11, 2012
            Messages:
            18,580
            Gender:
            Female
            Occupation:
            retired- blissfully retired......
            Location:
            Battle, East Sussex
            Ratings:
            +32,566
            It's been a great privilege to read all your comments about child management.
            All I know ( not having grandchildren) is that schools are finding they have more and more almost impossible to "manage" children. This has increased significantly in the last 5 years and is invariably to do with them not having a stable Mum and Dad home abckground .
            I do hope that your lovely, healthy views shine through - I'm certain they will for your offspring,
            Jenny namaste
             
            • Like Like x 2
            • Madahhlia

              Madahhlia Total Gardener

              Joined:
              Mar 19, 2007
              Messages:
              3,678
              Gender:
              Female
              Location:
              Suburban paradise
              Ratings:
              +3,090
              When I was a teenager in the 70s we thought disrespect of authority was cool and the only way forward. Society is paying the price of that now.
               
            • ARMANDII

              ARMANDII Low Flying Administrator Staff Member

              Joined:
              Jan 12, 2019
              Messages:
              48,096
              Gender:
              Male
              Ratings:
              +100,845
              Oh come on, Scrungee!! Surely you remember the old saying "Where's there's no sense, there's no feeling!!":doh::hate-shocked::heehee:


              Naah, the present law allows you to smack a child "but not leave a mark" and in a "reasonable" justifiable manner. Having said that there is always the danger of being brought to Court by some idiot who believes you should give in to everything.
              I was once clipped around the ear by the Neighbourhood PC who knew everyone.....and then got another smack from my Mum for getting a clip around the ear from him!!:hate-shocked::heehee:
               
              • Like Like x 1
              • Funny Funny x 1
              • Madahhlia

                Madahhlia Total Gardener

                Joined:
                Mar 19, 2007
                Messages:
                3,678
                Gender:
                Female
                Location:
                Suburban paradise
                Ratings:
                +3,090
                And look how nicely-behaved you are now!
                 
              • ARMANDII

                ARMANDII Low Flying Administrator Staff Member

                Joined:
                Jan 12, 2019
                Messages:
                48,096
                Gender:
                Male
                Ratings:
                +100,845
                I guess that shows that not everything will work!!:dunno::hate-shocked::heehee:
                 
              • Madahhlia

                Madahhlia Total Gardener

                Joined:
                Mar 19, 2007
                Messages:
                3,678
                Gender:
                Female
                Location:
                Suburban paradise
                Ratings:
                +3,090
                When I got whacked by the mean old Welsh teacher (she taught Welsh, I'm not being racist!) my Mum said I must have deserved it. She wasn't straight up to school demanding that the teacher be disciplined and reinforcing my bad behaviour in the process.
                 
              • ARMANDII

                ARMANDII Low Flying Administrator Staff Member

                Joined:
                Jan 12, 2019
                Messages:
                48,096
                Gender:
                Male
                Ratings:
                +100,845
                I always liked the old saying "I like children...but I couldn't eat a whole one:dunno:"
                 
                • Like Like x 1
                • shiney

                  shiney President, Grumpy Old Men's Club Staff Member

                  Joined:
                  Jul 3, 2006
                  Messages:
                  64,871
                  Gender:
                  Male
                  Occupation:
                  Retired - Last Century!!!
                  Location:
                  Herts/Essex border. Zone 8b
                  Ratings:
                  +127,052
                  So it's all your fault!!! :nonofinger: :lunapic 130165696578242 5:
                   
                • Madahhlia

                  Madahhlia Total Gardener

                  Joined:
                  Mar 19, 2007
                  Messages:
                  3,678
                  Gender:
                  Female
                  Location:
                  Suburban paradise
                  Ratings:
                  +3,090
                  I certainly put in a good effort.
                   
                  • Funny Funny x 1
                  Loading...

                  Share This Page

                  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
                    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
                    Dismiss Notice