Can you Please Help to ID this Succulent

I purchased a mixed bag of succulent cuttings last month, i was able to identify the others, most were Sedum, but this one has got me stumped.
Any idea's


Here's the Mother Leaf, which i removed today, this was the same colour as the pup's when planted

 

It looks like Pachyphytum clavifolia or if not then P. oviferum

 

@Michael Hewett your a star Sir thanks Michael

 

I think you'll be able to tell which one it is when it gets bigger. P. clavifolia has a more elongated pointy leaf than P. oviferum
The flowers are distinctive too so when it flowers you'll be able to know which one it is.

 

Thanks again Michael you’ve been a great help