How Good is my Photo..?? Discussion.. Any tips, Criticisms or Ideas Please..!!

That was a hard choice but colour I think @wiseowl. Even though there's very little colour in the top picture I think it softens the shot.

 

I agree colour the image doesn't pop as much in black and white

 

I also like the Black & White photo best. My days of Kodak Brownie are over so not a expert opinion just a observation. It seems to notice more in the colour photo but a distant photo enlarged in too much or perhaps sharpened too much in photoshop or something similar.There is a word for it but no idea so I will just use the word grainy,the water looks very grainy.
Having said all that,great photo and I would be very happy to take a photo like that.

 

This photo is excellent or double exposures.To me it is not overexposed at all,that is the perfect effect.I think to have the correct exposure if you know what I mean and a sharp rather than a "soft" focus would of completely spoil the effect you were after,excellent work.

 

To my eye, first 3 photos are excellent with good filter work,I presume or maybe photoshop work.
The 4th not so sure about, cannot decide what my eye should focus on?. The skyscrapers or the foreground or maybe the small tree in between the skyscrapers Nevertheless 4th photo still good work,keep it up.

 

Great photo,I also thought the expression was of a prisoner waiting for release

 

Much Much better in monochrome,well done.The monochrome gives it a more feeling of a tree that has died.

 

Original,too much contrast ,Red Filter ,not enough.
Blue spot on.

 

All the photos so far sent in by everyone are excellent and to be honest hard to give any judgement. It just goes to show it does not matter how good the camera or how you tweak the photo it is all down to the prep before you even press the shutter....composition.
A good view or even a bad one can be made great by trying different angles.Standing up, kneeling down,laying down,on some steps, etc. Once it is right you will know it. Always best for budding camera artists to try different things and framing is so so important.
Keep up the good work everyone and keep on sending in your photos.

 

Ooooohh i love this too. I do have a weakness for anything industrial